Published on
Urgent care clinicians generally approach patient care by leveraging both clinical experience and established evidence-based recommendations. But with ongoing research, prevailing practice guidelines evolve over time, and in some cases, guidelines from various sources may offer conflicting information. A new qualitative study involving 20 outpatient physicians published in BMC Primary Care found that while conflicting guidelines complicate clinical decisions, they do not prevent physicians from using the guidelines. Through semi-structured video interviews, researchers examined how clinicians manage conflicting clinical practice guidelines. Participants included 11 attending physicians , 8 residents, and 1 fellow, representing family medicine, general internal medicine, and internal medicine subspecialties. Physicians noted that they frequently encountered inconsistent recommendations and identified 5 approaches to resolving these guideline conflicts, which include: applying clinical judgment to individualize care; reviewing additional evidence or consulting colleagues; following familiar or trusted guidelines; involving patients in shared decision-making; and choosing the more aggressive recommendation. Most said they often combined approaches, with clinical judgment as their favored go-to strategy.
Real-world practice: In a situation when guidelines conflict and clinicians then rely on their own judgment, study participants said patient history and even “what my personal vibe is on the patient” are most helpful at the bedside.
