Urgent message: LGBTQ individuals are subject to implicit and explicit biases in our society, ranging from antagonistic legislation and microaggressions to overt harassment. This can inhibit willingness to seek medical care—and, subsequently, lead to worse health outcomes. Understanding how word choice and other subtle cues communicate competency in working with LGBTQ patients can help us engender trust.
Benjamin Silverberg, MD, MSc, FAAFP, FCUCM
The goals for treating LGBTQ patients (lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, and queer or questioning individuals) are the same as for anyone else: to facilitate physical health and social and emotional well-being. However, often due to preconceived notions and expectations, creating a strong, healthy therapeutic relationship with a new LGBTQ patient can be as challenging as it is essential.
Development of sexual orientation and gender identity and expression (SOGIE) is a rite of passage usually coinciding with puberty. This is why it’s important not to make assumptions even when working with children and adolescents. In the second decade of life, some individuals may feel something is “different” but not be able to quite put a finger on why (though it may have something to do with attraction, gender identity, or both). In middle adolescence (age 14-17), individuals may experiment sexually, which can lead to self-labeling. Previous research has suggested that the mean age for expression of feelings of sexual identity in boys/men is 14, but these milestones seem to be becoming progressively younger.1
Sex and gender are frequently conflated. They are, however, separate concepts. Sex is based on genetics and/or anatomic features at birth. Thus, a newborn is commonly labelled as a boy or a girl. Gender, on the other hand, is based on sociocultural expectations of what a “feminine” or “masculine” person looks like and does. A cisgender individual has gender identity and/or expression that match societal expectations of the sex assigned at birth; transgender individuals do not. Some individuals do not identify with or express themselves as either binary gender. Gender non-conforming (GNC) is a term that is losing momentum given its slight negative connotation, and instead, gender diverse may be preferable.2
Other dimensions of oneself include sexual identity (eg, straight, gay, lesbian, bisexual, pansexual, same-gender-loving), sexual orientation and romantic attraction, and sexual behavior—eg, men who have sex with men (MSM), women who have sex with men (WSM), etc. Sexual behavior—what people do—and identity (how people view themselves and present themselves to the world) are not always the same. Similarly, attraction is not necessarily synonymous with behavior. Further, sexual orientation can be dynamic, especially as a person figures out their identity over time.
As in other arenas, word choice matters; the challenge is that preferred words are always changing. Words fall out of favor or get repurposed. For example, “tranny” and “transgendered” are not acceptable, but “queer” has been reclaimed. In fact, queer has become a catch-all term for identities that are not heterosexual or cisgender. Be aware, however, that because the word has a history of being used as a slur, certain generations may still bristle at hearing this.
Estimating the size of the LGBTQ population can be difficult. Epidemiologic research often omits explicit questions about sexual orientation and gender identity, especially in younger age groups. Thus, the population may be “invisible” unless you ask the right questions. That said, whether you are aware of it or not, you are seeing patients who meet these descriptions! An estimated 9 million Americans across the age spectrum identify as LGBT. Though 8% of U.S. adults have engaged in same-sex sexual behavior and 11% acknowledge some same-sex sexual attraction, best prevalence figures suggest 3.5% of U.S. adults are LGB and 0.6% are transgender. These estimates are usually obtained through self-report conducted by advocacy groups. Collecting data like this is important, because if you don’t count someone, you’re telling them they don’t count.3-6
Social context encompasses a number of areas that lead to negative health outcomes for LGBTQ individuals: lack of positive role models, internalized phobias (ie, self-loathing), social stigma, loss of family support, discrimination, isolation, and even denial of healthcare services. These things result in negative physical and emotional outcomes. Higher rates of homelessness, unemployment, victimization, and adverse childhood experiences (ACEs) lead to chronic stress.7
What is normal?
Ethnocentrism is the belief that one’s own culture is superior to all others. It sows the seeds of bias and preconceived notions, and furthers the idea that one’s own customs are “the only way to do things.” In the context of LGBTQ populations, it can lead to the expectation that heterosexuality is the default—in other words, heteronormativity. Similarly, if it is expected that everyone is cisgender, cisnormativity develops. Recoil against gay or transgender populations, then, is homophobia or transphobia, respectively. As humans, we are not defined by one aspect of our identity. Intersectionality is how race, nationality, sexual orientation, gender identity, religion, disability, and the like play off one another, especially in the context of discrimination.
The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention defines health disparities among youth as “Preventable differences in the burden of disease, injury, violence, or opportunities to achieve optimal health that are experienced by socially-disadvantaged populations.”8 Alcohol and other drugs are sometimes used to self-medicate against loneliness and depression. Substance use is linked to higher-risk sex and sexually transmitted infections, suicide attempts, and motor vehicle accidents. Parental rejection, such as blaming the child for being bullied, is linked with negative health outcomes, especially depression and attempted suicide. LGBTQ youth of color are less likely than their Caucasian peers to be out to their parents. An estimated 20% to 50% of homeless street youth are LGBTQ, and they may engage in “survival sex” for money, food, shelter, and/or drugs. The incidence of new HIV infections is highest in MSM, especially in younger men and men of color.8
Older LGBTQ patients also experience health disparities. For example, gay, lesbian, bisexual, and transgender men and women are less likely to be offered appropriate screening for cancer.1,4,9-11
Per the 2015 Youth Risk Behavior Survey (YRBS), about a third of LGB students have been bullied on school property, and 10% or more have been threatened or experienced violence in various settings.12 The 2015 Canadian Trans Youth Health Survey reveals even higher numbers.13 Rates may be still higher for those who cannot “hide” or “blend in” as easily. Perpetrators may be peers, of course, but also family members, teachers, coaches, employers, or even police: The victim may not know where to turn (or whom to trust) for help.
Data from the 2015 YRBS reported 29% of LGB youth had attempted suicide at least once in the prior year, compared to 6% of heterosexual youth.12 Lack of support family/community support, family conflicts, violence/victimization (eg, feeling unsafe at school/bullying), gender noncomformity, early sexual debut, and other mental health issues (eg, substance use) fuel this.12
There are also high rates of suicide attempts among subgroups within the larger transgender community. Per the Williams Institute, 45% of trans-identified youth, 46% of transmen, and 42% of transwomen reported at least one suicide attempt, to date. Rejection by an authority figure is correlated with the highest suicidality, 60%. Conversely, appropriate use of a transgender person’s chosen name is linked to reduced depressive symptoms and suicidal ideation.14
Not surprisingly, many LGBTQ individuals have come to dread healthcare visits because they’ve had poor experiences in the past. This can lead to avoidance and undermine development of a strong patient-provider relationship. Whereas professional societies such as the American Academy of Pediatrics have advocated for LGBTQ populations for many years, individual providers and health systems have been slower to consider the unique needs of these groups. To be sure, surveys have revealed that one in three transgender respondents have had a negative experience with a healthcare provider in the preceding year. Some report having been verbally harassed or even refused medical treatment. One in four actually had to teach their provider about transgender healthcare. Insurance coverage is often an issue for transgender individuals, made all the more difficult by higher rates of unemployment in this community. When visiting a new provider, it can be upsetting for LGBTQ individuals to have to “come out” all over again, with regard to sexual orientation and/or gender identity, especially if they experienced rejection in the past.10,15
Experiencing discrimination in healthcare settings is associated with delays in testing and treatment, fewer provider visits, decreased preventative health services including cancer screening, delays in filling prescriptions, and decreased patient satisfaction overall.
THE URGENT CARE VISIT
Opportunities to Improve Care
Sex discrimination in federally funded healthcare facilities is specifically prohibited by the Affordable Care Act. But we can do better than simply avoiding discrimination. We can work to make our clinics safe and welcoming to all people. We can train our front desk staff to tactfully navigate potentially awkward situations. We can rewrite inequitable policies.
The clinical space is an area where we can work to display cultural humility. Two other areas that are not always thought of involve follow-up: patient satisfaction surveys (are you doing a good job fixing systemic issues in giving good care?) and tracking health outcomes (such as HIV testing and alcohol misuse). You cannot easily improve what is not measured!16
The front desk
Sometimes there will be a discrepancy between a patient’s presented gender and what is on their ID card, health documentation, or medical chart. Some, but not all medical records have a place for a patient’s chosen name. Typically it is best to ask someone “What would you like to be called?” (accepting that this may differ from the patient’s legal name). Most transgender individuals recognize that their legal name needs to be used in certain documents, but calling someone by the name that doesn’t reflect their gender identity is called “deadnaming.” This can be very offensive, especially after someone has corrected the speaker.
Additionally, it is typically best to ask someone what pronouns they use. Misgendering a transgender individual is like a bee sting: It hurts, but the more it happens, the bigger the reaction. Things a cisgender person might take for granted every day are a challenge for transgender individuals, and since they may even expect care to be insensitive, they are already in a defensive position. That said, conversations about names and pronouns should be handled discretely, so as not to “out” someone in the waiting room.
Remember, too, that handoffs of care are not just between you and a consultant, but also among your own staff. It can be frustrating for patients when staff fail to communicate already-disclosed gender identity information to one another.4
In addition to common areas being clean, include representation of your patients in posters, brochures, and magazines. Visual clues like rainbow pins or equality stickers will be noticed by those who “need to know.” Proactively address confidentiality concerns and post statements on nondiscrimination and visitation rules. Use gender-neutral terms on forms and in addressing individuals.
If possible, have an accessible, single-use, all-gender restroom facility for patients. Many transgender and non-binary individuals avoid public bathrooms. This means not eating or drinking, and consequently, these individuals may experience episodes of hypoglycemia, dehydration, urinary tract infections, or other kidney problems.15
Be aware of appropriate and welcoming places to refer patients to when needed for mental health care, for example, or management of gender-affirming hormone therapy. OutCare, which is based in Indianapolis, has a directory of self-identified LGBTQ-competent healthcare providers. The Gay and Lesbian Medical Association and the Human Rights Campaign’s Healthcare Equality Index are other places to look to help expand your network.1,2
The exam room (and beyond)
In the exam room, or even more generally the clinical space (eg, x-ray suite, phlebotomy room), there are several principles of good communication that apply for working with pretty much any patient population. First, make sure the patient is comfortable with whomever else is in the room, and allow them to decline the presence of anyone not directly responsible for their care (for example, trainees).
Providers and other staff can build rapport by setting a respectful and honest tone. In the patient interview, use open-ended questions to avoid simple yes/no responses that may imply there is a “correct” answer. “Tell me more” is a wonderful way to show you are listening and interested. Similarly, normalizing language that makes personal questions seem more general can be helpful.
As mentioned earlier, word choice matters, but it’s sometimes challenging because slang is always changing. If appropriate, echo back the patient’s word choice, but if you’re not sure what they mean, seek clarification. “Can you explain it to me? is not meant to preclude your own research and study of, for example, gender-affirming hormone therapy, but a way to further engage with your patient. If you misspeak and misuse a word or make an incorrect assumption, acknowledge it, apologize, and move on. Ignoring the issue won’t make it go away and offering profuse and repeated apologies only amplify the error. Ultimately, patients are seeking medically knowledgeable care, and in some cases, the exam room may be the only place they can ask questions and get accurate information. Less than a third of LGBT adolescents felt they had an adult they could talk to about personal problems, for instance. Remember that you don’t need to know a patient’s sexual orientation or gender identity to create a safe space for them to disclose relevant health information.2,4
Assumptions to try to avoid include misgendering or mis-assuming the nature of a relationship or family structure. Sometimes in urgent care we do have continuity with patients, so remember that some aspects of their identity may change with time. Self-identification does not always align with behavior. For instance, an individual may have had same-sex or opposite-sex “experimentation” when they were younger but determined their sexual orientation later in life. Gender identity and expression do not imply a particular sexual orientation or practice. Similarly, acknowledging one risk (such as not using condoms) doesn’t necessarily imply the patient has other risky behaviors (such as IV drug use).2,17
Confidentiality is often a big worry for adolescents; in general, they fear disclosure of sexual activity, let alone sexuality. But this is also true whenever we’re asking for personal information. Some patients don’t want a “paper trail” and may not be truthful on paper forms. Conversely, they may wonder why they were asked certain questions if their answers are never addressed during the interview. These questions can be framed in the context of risk: “I ask these questions because I’m trying to determine what tests, if any, we should perform today.” Consider mentioning the role of the medical record as well: “Everything you tell me is between you, me, and the computer—unless you tell me you’re going to hurt yourself or someone else.” A patient may express some uncertainty about their gender identity to you, but not be ready for others to know about this doubt yet, for example.1
The sexual history
The stated reason for the visit is not always the patient’s real chief concern. LGBTQ health includes, but is not defined by, sexual health. Thus, STI screening should be based on behavior, not identity (ie, names/labels). Seek the patient’s permission to discuss sexual health topics, if appropriate. The CDC has suggested five different elements in taking a sexual history (the so-called “5 Ps”).18
The physical exam
As with any patient, do not ask about—or perform unnecessary examination of—body parts not relevant to the chief concern. If necessity of an aspect of the exam is not obvious, consider explaining why you are doing what you are doing. Physical examination should be relevant to what anatomy the patient has, regardless of their gender presentation. In most institutions, a staff member chaperones intimate exams. This is probably a good habit to get into, regardless of the sex and gender of the patient and the provider. If possible, allow patients to self-collect or self-swab vaginal and anal/rectal test specimens.
Considerations related to gender affirmation
Though not every transgender individual wants to—or can afford to—undergo medical and surgical treatment (eg, puberty-blockers, onabotulinumtoxin A), knowing trustworthy consultants (eg, endocrinologists) in your area is helpful. Mental health support is probably in needed in all phases of coming out and gender-affirmation.
Social and medical affirmation (previously known as transition) can lead to some unique considerations for our transgender patients. Binding one’s breasts to achieve a more masculine contour can lead to skin irritation and breakdown and reduce lung expansion, causing dyspnea or even lung infections. Taping or tucking male genitals can also lead to skin problems or hernias. Injection of silicone or other substances can lead to skin infections or worse, especially when the chemicals are not of medical-grade for humans. In the same way that some people who can’t afford a prescription for an antibiotic may use medications intended for pets, sometimes animal hormones are used. These illicit injections are also unmonitored by healthcare professionals, so supraphysiologic doses could be administered unintentionally. Even appropriately dosed and administered hormones can carry risks, such as cardiovascular disease, hypertension, hyperlipidemia, liver dysfunction, breast cancer, and uterine cancer. Further, there is a lack of clinical evidence as to what the long-term health effects of hormone therapy will be.10
It bears repeating that testosterone is not birth control. One way to broach the topic in a respectful way would be to ask, “I would like to order an x-ray for you. If there’s any chance you could be pregnant, we will need to check a pregnancy test first. Is that okay with you?”
Other Sources of Information
Many professional societies and health entities have their own LGBTQ resources. The American Academy of Family Physicians has an LGBT health toolkit, for example. WPATH and the UCSF Center for Excellence in Transgender Health are both renowned resources for information on transgender health. SAGE is an organization that focuses on older LGBTQ individuals. The National LGBT Health Education Center has free CME on LGBTQ health issues. Resources for patients, their families, and providers are listed in Table 1 and Table 2.1,4,17
Whether you identify as an LGBTQ individual or an ally, be engaged in your community. Allow it to tell you what it needs. Healthcare providers can often dictate what happens in their own practices. Self-evaluation is important, as you work at every level of the socioecological model (ie, individual, interpersonal, organization, community, and societal levels) to improve care. As with any other group, keep learning so you can provide timely, relevant health information. Lead by example; challenge offensive language and learn if you yourself have misspoken. We can do better to be inclusive of all our patients.
|Table 1. Resources for Patients and Families|
|• For LGBTQ+ youth and/or their parents
─ Parents, Families, and Friends of Lesbians and Gays (pflag.org)
─ The “It Gets Better” Project (itgetsbetter.org)
─ The Trevor Project (thetrevorproject.org)
─ GLBT National Health Center (glbthotline.org)
• General LGBTQ+ resources
─ Gay, Lesbian, and Straight Education Network (glsen.org)
─ Human Rights Campaign (hrc.org)
─ Lambda Legal (lambdalegal.org)
─ The Fenway Institute (thefenwayinstitute.org)
|Table 2. Resources for Providers|
|• American Academy of Family Physician’s LGBT Health Toolkit (www.aafp.org/patient-care/public-health/lgbt-toolkit.html)
• World Professional Association for Transgender Health (wpath.org)
• UCSF Center of Excellence in Transgender Health (transhealth.ucsf.edu)
• UCSF LGBT Resource Center (lgbt.ucsf.edu)
• Services and Advocacy for GLBT Elders (sageusa.org)
• Gay and Lesbian Medical Association (glma.org)
• National LGBT Health Education Center (LGBThealtheducation.org)
• TransLine (protect-health.org/transline)
Adapted from “Providing the Best Care for LGBTQ+ Patients in UC,” presented electronically for the Urgent Care Association’s 2020 annual conference.
The author would like to thank Susan Boisvert, BSN MHSA DFASHRM; Ruben Hopwood, MDiv PhD; and Ellen Rodrigues, PhD for their thoughtful feedback during the development of this article. He would also like to thank Callie Matheny, Carla Jamison, and Joseph Toscano, MD for their support and guidance.
- Garofalo R. Adapted by The Fenway Institute. Caring for LGBTQ youth. The Fenway Guide to LGBT Health. Module 4. 2015.
- Quallich S, Mitchell K, eds. Manual of Men’s Health: A Practice Guide for APRNs and PAs. New York, NY: Springer Publishing Company, LLC; 2018:46-48, 118-121, 231-241.
- Goodman M, Adams N, Corneil T, et al. Size and distribution of transgender and gender nonconforming populations. Endocrinol Metab Clin N Am, 2019;48(2):303-321.
- Gorton RN, Berdahl CT. Improving the quality of emergency care for transgender patients. Ann Emerg Med. 2018;71(2):189-192.
- Pantalone DW, Haldeman DC, Martell CR. Health care issues facing lesbian, gay, bisexual, and transgender individuals. In: Sahler OJZ, Carr JE, Frank JB, Nunves JV, eds. The Behavioral Sciences and Health Care. 4th ed. Boston, MA: Hogrefe Publishing Corporation; 2017:175-182.
- Samenow CP, Salas-Ramirez KY. Sexuality and sexual disorders. In: Sahler OJZ, Carr JE, Frank JB, Nunves JV, eds. The Behavioral Sciences and Health Care. 4th ed. City, ST: Publisher; 2017:163-173.
- Artiga S, Hinton E. Beyond health care: the role of social determinants in promoting health and health equity. Henry J Kaiser Family Foundation, Issue Brief. 2018.
- Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Adolescent and School Health. Health disparities. Available at: https://bit.ly/3h5RMlp. Accessed August 28, 2020.
- Gayles TA, Garofalo R. Exploring the Health Issues of LGBTQ Adolescents. In: Schneider JS, Silenzio VMB, Erickson-Schroth L, eds. The GLMA Handbook on LGBT Health. 1st ed. Santa Barbara, CA: Praeger; 2019:133-153.
- Lapinski J, Covas T, Perkins JM, et al. Best practices in transgender health: a clinician’s guide. Prim Care Clin Office Pract, 2018;45(4):687-703.
- Skidmore WC, Simone MJ, Eskildsen MA, et al. The health of LGBT elders. In: Schneider JS, Silenzio VMB, Erickson-Schroth L, eds. The GLMA Handbook on LGBT Health. 1st ed. Santa Barbara, CA: Praeger; 2019:155-183.
- Kann L, McManus T, Harris WA, et al. Youth Risk Behavior Surveillance – United States, 2017. Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report: Surveillance Summaries, 2018;67(SS-8):1-114.
- Veale J, Saewyc E, Frohard-Dourlent H, et al. Being safe, being me: results of the Canadian Trans Youth Health Survey. Vancouver, BC: Stigma and Resilience Among Vulnerable Youth Centre, School of Nursing, University of British Columbia.
- Williams Institute. Suicide Attempts Among Transgender and Gender Non-Conforming Adults. Findings from the National Transgender Discrimination Survey. 2014. Available at: https://williamsinstitute.law.ucla.edu/wp-content/uploads/Trans-GNC-Suicide-Attempts-Jan-2014.pdf. Accessed August 28, 2020.
- Headley M. Improving transgender patient care. Patient Safety & Quality Healthcare. Available at: https://www.psqh.com/analysis/improving-transgender-patient-care/. Accessed February 7, 2020.
- Bruessow D, Ng H, Wilson-Stronks A. When a welcoming health care environment matters most. In: The GLMA Handbook on LGBT Health. Schneider JS, Silenzio VMB, Erickson-Schroth L, eds. 1st ed. Santa Barbara, CA: Praeger; 2019:211-222.
- Jalali S, Sauer LM. Improving care for lesbian, gay, bisexual, and transgender patients in the emergency department. Ann Emerg Med. 2015;66(4):417-23.
- Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. A guide to taking a sexual history. Available at: https://www.cdc.gov/std/treatment/sexualhistory.pdf. Accessed August 28, 2020.
Benjamin Silverberg, MD, MSc, FAAFP, FCUCM is an Assistant Professor in the Departments of Emergency Medicine and Family Medicine at West Virginia University, and the Medical Director of the Division of Physician Assistant Studies in the Department of Human Performance at West Virginia University. He reports no relevant financial relationships with any commercial interests.