Bouncebacks
The Case of a 17-Year-Old Male
with Fever and Headache
Bouncebacks, in which we recount scenarios of actual patients who were evaluated in and discharged from
an emergency department or urgent care facility and then “bounced back” for further treatment, appears
semimonthly in JUCM.
Case presentations on each patient, along with case-by-case risk management commentary by Gregory L.
Henry, past president of The American College of Emergency Physicians, and discussions by other nationally
recognized experts are detailed in the book Bouncebacks! Emergency Department Cases: ED returns (2006,
Anadem Publishing, www.anadem.com).] Also available at www.amazon.com and www.acep.org.
Michael B. Weinstock, MD and Ryan Longstreth, MD, FACEP
T his article is the third in a series in
which we will sequentially
answering the following ques-
tions: I. What is the incidence of
bouncebacks? II. What is the inci-
dence of bounce-
back admissions?
III. What is the inci-
dence of deaths in
patients recently
discharged from the
ED? om
IV. What percent of
s.c ge
ma / r I
bouncebacks occur
ble Sta
because of medical
on a B rt
© errors?
V. How can we use this
information to im-
prove patient safety?
This month, we will discuss Ques-
tion III: What is the incidence of deaths in
patients recently discharged from the ED?
In May 2007, Sklar et al performed a very interesting
study concerning deaths that occurred within seven
days of ED discharge. A similar study had been done in
w w w. j u c m . c o m
1994 by Kefer et al, looking at medical ex-
aminer cases.
Sklar’s study, however, is more likely to
have captured all unanticipated deaths
because it was performed at the Univer-
sity of New Mexico Health Sciences
Center, an urban tertiary care cen-
ter and the University of New
Mexico’s only medical school
and Level I trauma center.
The Sklar study was a retro-
spective cohort of ED patients
who were discharged to home.
Ten-year data review of
387,334 ED visits identified
117 patients who died
within seven days of being
discharged from the ED,
equating to a death rate of
30/100,000. Of the 117 patients, 50% (58
total patients) died of complica-
tions related to the initial visit;
60% of those 58 patients died due to a
possible medical error (35 of the total 117 patients).
Frequent initial complaints included CNS symptoms
(i.e., seizure, headache, dizziness), abdominal pain,
JUCM T h e J o u r n a l o f U r g e n t C a r e M e d i c i n e | J a n u a r y 2 0 0 8
21