Bouncebacks
The Case of a 46-Year-Old Man
with Neck and Upper Back Pain
Bouncebacks, in which we recount scenarios of actual patients who were evaluated in and discharged
from an emergency department or urgent care facility and then “bounced back” for further treatment,
appears semimonthly in JUCM.
Case presentations on each patient, along with case-by-case risk management commentary by Gregory
L. Henry, past president of The American College of Emergency Physicians, and discussions by other na-
tionally recognized experts are detailed in the book Bouncebacks! Emergency Department Cases: ED
returns (2006, Anadem Publishing, www.anadem.com).
Michael B. Weinstock, MD and Ryan Longstreth, MD, FACEP
T his article is the second in a series
that will sequentially answer
the following questions:
What is the incidence of
bouncebacks? What is the incidence of
bounceback admissions?
What is the incidence
of deaths in patients re-
cently discharged from
the ED?
What percent of bounce-
backs occur because of
medical errors?
m How can we use this in-
.co es
ag I / m
formation to improve pa-
ler tab
tient safety?
nS t ar o
B ©
In the September issue of
JUCM, we discussed several
studies which found the in-
cidence of ED bouncebacks is
3%; of the 115 million ED visits
per year in the U.S., approximately 3.3
million patients will “bounce back” to the ED
within 72 hours.
This month, we turn our attention to Question II:
What is the incidence of bounceback admissions?
w w w. j u c m . c o m
The most comprehensive recent study
of bounceback admissions (Martin-Gill,
et al, Am J Emerg Med) spanned a two-
year period with 104,584 new patients
seen and discharged; 609 patients
(0.58%) were admitted within 72
hours of their initial ED visit.
Other studies have reached
similar conclusions.
Martin-Gill found the fol-
lowing groups more likely to
be admitted on ED return:
Ⅲ Age >65 (three times more
likely to require admission
than patients <30 years of
age) Patient with the follow-
ing diagnoses:
Ⅲ mental disorder
Ⅲ GU system disorder/
UTI and urinary calculus
Ⅲ alcohol-related disorder
Ⅲ abdominal pain
Ⅲ chest pain
The direct answer to the question of bounceback ad-
missions—0.6%—equates to roughly 660,000 patients
per year.
JUCM T h e J o u r n a l o f U r g e n t C a r e M e d i c i n e | N o v e m b e r 2 0 0 7
21